Neither.

Nov 04, 2018,21:47 PM
 

Keep looking until you find the one you will fall in love with. Then you will not be asking for advice. 

Of course if you are looking for investment advice, that is a different story.
Good luck with your search.
Cheers
Jim



  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

2 watches ...2 styles...1choice...

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : November 4th, 2018-10:45
Advice needed!! Kev ...  

Dress or casual? [nt]

 
 By: pmh6000 : November 4th, 2018-10:52

well I weara suit to work everyday

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : November 5th, 2018-13:30
but the rest of the time it's Jean/converse ...(I look very young...) Kev

Sports model! [nt]

 
 By: jonrus : November 4th, 2018-11:00

Totally different watches (obviously) but ...

 
 By: JohnFM : November 4th, 2018-11:07
... both are fantastic choices. Get the one that sings to you -- period. While I would probably go for the Rolex because of my casual lifestyle, along with its versatility and sturdiness, the Calatrava is the ultimate dress watch. My favorite Patek is eit... 

Funny enough

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : November 4th, 2018-11:42
They very first time I saw the calatrava with this bezel I hated it. But surprisingly I really love it now. My other issue is probably the size of the Rolex on my wrist? Kev

haha nice

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : November 5th, 2018-11:50
I am actually hesitating between that one and the root beer one (but never had the chance to see it in real yet) if I go for the sport one... Kev

get the PP [nt]

 
 By: Passionata_george : November 4th, 2018-11:16

TBH i don t like any supercased Rolex

 
 By: Passionata_george : November 5th, 2018-12:21
zero.A nice 5digit GMT d be totally different story but in this case rather a nice dresss patek than the batman.

what about the root beer?

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : November 5th, 2018-13:31
Kev

Rolex now and maybe Patek later

 
 By: 1WatchMan : November 4th, 2018-11:31
You can either add the Patek later or replace the Rolex if you find that it wasn't the right choice. This is my advice without any context info. Two totally different watches, but you already know it 😉

No contest

 
 By: ptug : November 4th, 2018-11:37
Sadly for me. The Rolex all day long !! Have fun choosing.

The Rolex for a sports model at this price point.

 
 By: Cpt Scarlet : November 4th, 2018-11:43
For an equivalent Patek you need to look higher up the Patek tree.

Batman [nt]

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : November 4th, 2018-11:45

I owned a 5120J

 
 By: TS1987 : November 4th, 2018-11:50
Fell out of love with it within four weeks. Wasn't worth the expense or the grief it gave.

May we ask

 
 By: xxn : November 4th, 2018-23:37
What such grief entailed? Thx.

Bought it freshly serviced according to paperwork with it.

 
 By: TS1987 : November 5th, 2018-04:26
Screws were found to be loose visible though caseback, it ran poorly. It actually stopped one day and I didn't realise I was late for a business meeting... Oops

Gmt is a worthwhile complaint to have...

 
 By: mahesh : November 4th, 2018-12:05
Batman is great looking & not easy to get too. Go for it. PP - I’m sure you can find again in future even less than retail but not the batman. Best, mahesh.,

If it is a Nautilus 5711 or 5712...

 
 By: Greenwatch : November 4th, 2018-14:32
I would say Patek but not the Calatrava for now. It’s easy to get if you want one later. It’s the Rolex GMT2 BLNR for now. Good luck!

I can’t give you any advice

 
 By: RussW : November 4th, 2018-14:54
But I would buy the Rolex. I prefer sportier watches so it would suit me better. For a simple Calatrava I like the 5196 more.

As a Rolex and patek owner...

 
 By: Wristenthusiast : November 4th, 2018-15:16
I would go Rolex if I could only have one. It's an appropriate watch pretty much anywhere. My patek dress watches are beautiful pieces of art, but I can't wear them when working on equipment or banging around or near water. Rolex watches wear scratches we... 

The Rolex.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : November 4th, 2018-16:48
I find the Patek far too classic (even old fashioned) in design/style.

I kinda found that at the very first sight

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : November 5th, 2018-11:47
but since I tried it on, i quite enjoy it. Tbh, I like the 240 movement more than the watch itself thouugh Kev

Very true indeed...

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : November 7th, 2018-10:56
Kev

Food for thought?

 
 By: Mister M : November 6th, 2018-19:13
...  

Thanks for the advise

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : November 7th, 2018-10:58
I am not a big fan yet of gd seiko. For the moment I am trying to stay within omega, Rolex, Patek, AP or jlc Kev

Neither.

 
 By: jimjenkins : November 4th, 2018-21:47
Keep looking until you find the one you will fall in love with. Then you will not be asking for advice. Of course if you are looking for investment advice, that is a different story. Good luck with your search. Cheers Jim

This is very good advice [nt]

 
 By: watch-er : November 5th, 2018-07:14

Personally I will go for the batman Rolex gmt.

 
 By: geross : November 5th, 2018-12:38
I am more of a casual guy. In my get up. And it's warm here in the tropics. Regarding the 5120g, I would go more with the 5196r or J. As a dress watch. Because it has a seconds hand and minute markers. My opinion. Geross 😉